As a child I was always spanked if I didn't listen so there is a part of me that says it's okay that I spanked Olivia. But there is a part of me that says just because I was hit and my parents were hit it's still not okay to ever put your hands on a child no matter the reason. I couldn't decide which one is right so I asked my parents, grandma and sister what they thought.
"Yes, when words don't get through to a kid then as a last resort you have to hit them" is what my mom said.
I then asked my dad the same question; Is it okay to hit your kids?
"It's alright to hit your kids to a certain extent because if you just beat them then you're not teaching them discipline, you are just making them fear you and that's not parenting."
"Yes, but you should only hit them on the butt" is what my grandma said.
"When Olivia just doesn't listen after all the yelling I do to try to get her to do what I say I just have to spank her so she knows that I'm serious."
They all said that hitting your child was alright to do as a last resort and only to a certain point. Being Mexican, I expected them to say that because everyone in my family including cousins uncles aunts and everyone in between was hit as a child. Then I thought to myself, what would a white woman say? What would a black woman say? Would the white woman say that it's never okay to hit a child even though her son cusses at her and disrespects her? What would the black woman say?
I don't think it matters what color your skin is or what family you were raised in. People all over the world have their own ways of punishing and disciplining their children. I don't plan on being a parent anytime soon, and that makes me really happy because I wouldn't know what to do. Do I spank this kid or take the risk of him walking all over me because I never physically punished him? This is the challenge that parents face with their children and I feel bad for them. I gave my sweet little Olive one slap on the butt and I felt like scum so I can only imagine what they go through.
I struggled with this question as I raised my girls. I decided I didn't want to spank because I usually spanked when I lost my temper. It seems like a bad model if you're doing it out of rage or loss of control.
ReplyDeleteI was in child development class my freshmen year and I learned that parents shouldn't hit their child because it makes the child fear them. Instead of slapping her in the butt, have you ever tried to punish her by sitting in a corner or no dessert after dinner?
ReplyDeleteI think the whole putting a child in the corner thing is just pointless (no offense Joyce) but it doesn't make the child learn anything. As seargant Hale says "positive behavior, gets possitive results.)
ReplyDelete